Finally, somebody listens to me on what should be done to punish sex offenders:
Louisiana Lawmakers Consider Castration for Sex Offenders
BATON ROUGE, La. — Castration could be a sentencing option for some sex offenders in Louisiana under a bill approved by a state Senate judiciary committee.
The bill by Senator Nick Gautreaux, an Abbeville Democrat, requires a judge to order treatment for certain second-offense sex criminals with a specific drug designed to diminish male sexual urges — if a medical expert agrees that the treatment would be effective.
An offender who doesn’t want the treatment could opt for physical castration. Gautreaux says some offenders may indeed want castration in hopes of avoiding the drug’s side effects or permanently ending the sexual urges that led to their crimes. His bill goes next to the full Senate.
I’ve discussed how best to punish sex offenders previously. Given the high rates of recidivism of sex criminals, I still don’t understand why we ever let them out to become second-, third-, and fourth-time offenders. That said, since no one has bought on to my original plan of life in prison for all the pervs, this LA law is a close second. Sure, we’ll let you out, Mr. Disgusting Pervert… most of you, that is.
The American Civil Liberties Union of Louisiana doesn’t quite see things the same way I do:
Bills ranged from modest changes to existing statutes to castration (SB 3 by Nick Gautreaux) to humorous, such as Nick Gautreaux’s SB 254 which would have prohibited sex offenders from wearing masks on Halloween.
Rather than spending precious lobby time on bills that were sure to pass, we elected instead to make a general statement in committee near the beginning of the session, decrying the majority of the bills as “feel good” legislation which do little to reduce sex abuse, and reminding the legislators that they have done little or nothing in the areas of treatment and prevention.
While I am intrigued as to why the ACLU of LA thinks a law prohibiting criminal sex offenders from disguising themselves during a holiday geared toward children going door to door asking strangers for candy is “humorous”, I do have a more pressing question: exactly who will “feel good” if the castration law is passed? I’m going to guess it’s not the sex offenders. That must be why the ACLU is upset.
On a more serious note, statistics repeatedly show that sex offenders are more likely than other criminals to repeat their crime after being released from prison. Therefore, castration of second-time offenders would inherently prevent some sex abuse. Furthermore, if you want to discuss “treatment”… wouldn’t castration fit that bill as well? CURED!



Recent Comments